Why did Afterpay reject my dispute because the merchant says the package was shipped to the right country?

BNPL & Installment Payments

Afterpay likely rejected the dispute because “shipped to the right country” is not the same as “not delivered to you.” A parcel can enter the correct country and still be lost, misdelivered, delivered to the wrong address, or handed to a pickup point without reaching you.

What matters next is the difference between country-level shipping proof and proof of actual delivery.

Do this now, in this order:

  • Open the tracking and find the last scan.
  • If it only says things like “arrived in destination country,” “cleared customs,” or “in transit,” that is not proof of delivery to your address.
  • If it says “delivered,” check whether it shows the delivery date, time, and the exact address, pickup point, or recipient details.
  • Compare the tracking with your order address.
  • Check the full shipping address in the order confirmation.
  • If the parcel was sent to the right country but the wrong city, postcode, or street, that is important evidence.
  • If the address is correct but there is no delivery scan, the merchant’s statement only proves dispatch or routing, not that you received the item.
  • Save the evidence that helps your case.
  • Order confirmation showing the shipping address
  • Full tracking history, not just the last line
  • Any proof of delivery, photo, signature, or pickup notification if the carrier provides it
  • Messages where the merchant says the parcel was only shipped to the right country

Then go back to the Afterpay dispute file and check what reason they used for the rejection. The exact wording matters because Afterpay may have treated this as a “merchant shipped” case rather than a “item not received” or “wrong delivery address” case. If the dispute page or email lets you ask for a review, submit the missing proof and point out the gap: shipment to the correct country does not prove delivery to your address.

If the tracking shows a final delivery scan, your next step depends on where it says the parcel went:

  • If it was delivered to your address, ask the carrier for proof of delivery and compare the name, photo, or signature with your order.
  • If it was delivered elsewhere, ask the carrier and Afterpay to treat it as misdelivery and include the tracking number, delivery scan, and your order address.
  • If there is no delivery scan at all, tell Afterpay that the merchant’s evidence shows only destination-country shipment, not receipt by you.

If you need to contact the merchant or carrier, ask for a document or tracking record that shows the final delivery point, not just the destination country. Include the order number, tracking number, and the exact delivery address from the order.

Practical tip: a screenshot that ends with “arrived in your country” usually will not beat a dispute rejection unless you also show there was no valid delivery to your address.